Africa's New Blue Ocean. See our 2023 outlook. Download PDF

Supreme Court Declares Public-Sector Pension Schemes are not Subject to Procurement Laws

The  Supreme Court of Kenya in Association of Retirement Benefits Schemes v Attorney General & 3 others (Petition E017 of 2024) [2026] KESC 36 (KLR) (15 May 2026) (Judgment) by a majority decision (Koome CJ, Mwilu DCJ, Lenaola and Ouko SCJJ; Ndungu SCJ dissenting), held that Section 2(o) of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act (PPADA), which classified pension funds of public entities as “public entities” subject to public procurement laws, was unconstitutional to the extent of that inclusion.

The dispute arose pursuant to Section 2(o) of the PPADA which had included retirement benefit schemes sponsored by public bodies under the public procurement regime. The Appellant, the Association of Retirement Benefits Schemes, argued that pension funds are private trust arrangements established under the Retirement Benefits Act (RB Act), funded through employee and employer contributions, and held in trust for members rather than constituting public funds. The Appellant, on that basis, challenged the constitutionality of Section 2(o) of the PPADA.

The High Court and Court of Appeal had previously upheld the provision, reasoning that public sector pension schemes perform public functions, are regulated by the State, and therefore qualify as public entities subject to procurement oversight. However, the Supreme Court in its Judgment, overturned those decisions.

Supreme Court held that once the contributions made into an employee’s account in the pension scheme, it ceases to be public property. The funds become part of a private trust fund, held and managed by trustees for the exclusive benefit of the members. The Supreme Court also found that trustees, managers, administrators and custodians of a pension fund sponsored by an employer do not execute Government functions and are not remunerated from the Consolidated Fund or from money authorized by Parliament. To the contrary, their functions and powers are, by the provisions of the RB Act, defined and governed by the terms of a trust deed.

 

The Supreme Court emphasized that Article 227 of the Constitution, 2010 applies only to procurement by “state organs” and “public entities” using public money. The Apex Court consequently found that pension funds established by public employers do not meet that constitutional threshold to qualify as a public entity because, once contributions are paid into the scheme, they cease being public money and become private trust property held for employees’ benefit.

The Supreme Court went further to hold that contributions by both employer and employee constitute the employees’ private property, derived from earned income and held in trust for the employees’ benefit.

In the upshot, the Supreme Court distinguished between public oversight and State ownership or control. It held that the defining feature of entities contemplated under Article 227 of the Constitution is the use of public money appropriated through the budgetary process. Pension funds, even when sponsored by public employers, are not financed through public appropriations but through employees’ savings held in trust.

Consequently, the Supreme Court declared Section 2(o) of the PPADA inconsistent with Article 227(1) of the Constitution and void to the extent that it subjected pension funds of public entities to public procurement systems.

 

Implications of the Decision on Retirement Benefit Funds Established by Public Entities

The decision has major legal, operational, and financial implications for public sector retirement benefit schemes, they include:

  1. Removal from the PPADA procurement regime: pension schemes sponsored by public entities are no longer required to comply with the procurement procedures under the PPADA, including tendering requirements, procurement planning, advertising, approvals, and procurement litigation processes.
  2. Recognition of pension funds as private trust property: the Judgment firmly establishes that pension contributions belong to employees and beneficiaries, not to the sponsoring public employer or the State. This reinforces the trust structure under the RB Act and protects pension assets from being treated as public finances.
  3. Enhanced operational autonomy of trustees: trustees of public sector retirement schemes regain autonomy in procuring services such as fund management, actuarial services, administration systems, insurance, custodial services, and investment advisory services without being bound by the rigid PPADA framework.
  4. Reduction in compliance and administrative costs: the Appellant argued that compliance with PPADA imposed significant costs through procurement departments, tender procedures, advertising, and litigation risks, thereby diminishing members’ retirement benefits. The Judgment removes these obligations, thereby reducing operational expenses borne by schemes.
  5. Potential increase in procurement flexibility and efficiency: retirement schemes can now procure investment and professional services quicker and competitively within the framework of trust law and RB Act governance standards, which may improve investment responsiveness and fund administration.
  6. Continued regulation under the RB Act: although exempted from PPADA, public sector pension schemes remain regulated under the RB Act and under the oversight of the Retirement Benefits Authority. The Court clarified that regulation by the Authority continues, but such regulation does not convert the schemes into public entities.
  7. Precedential clarification of “public entity”: the decision narrows the constitutional meaning of “public entity” for procurement purposes and may influence future disputes involving entities that are regulated by government but funded privately.
  8. Possible legislative and policy reforms: the Court acknowledged concerns about accountability and corruption risks in pension schemes but held that such concerns cannot justify unconstitutional expansion of procurement law. Parliament or regulators may therefore consider developing sector-specific procurement or governance rules for retirement schemes outside the PPADA framework.

The decision marks a major development in Kenya’s pension and public procurement jurisprudence.

Safety as a Culture, not a Compliance Checklist

Every year on April 28th, the world observes the Day for Safety and Health at Work.  It is an opportunity to reflect on how employers are effectively protecting their workforce. As workplace dynamics continue to evolve, the conversation around occupational safety and health often centres on a single question: Are we compliant?

Between July 2023 and May 2024, the Directorate of Occupational Safety and Health Services (DOSHS) recorded 4,357 workers involved in workplace accidents across Kenya. These are not just normal statistics. They are breadwinners, parents, and colleagues who left for work one morning and did not return home safely or at all.

Yet, the common response in many Kenyan organisations remains largely unchanged. Most organisations focus on renewing the Work Injuries Benefits Act insurance cover, updating the safety register, scheduling the annual DOSHS inspection, and moving on. While the checklist is ticked, the underlying safety culture often does not change.

 

What the law Provides on Occupational Safety

Kenya has a reasonably solid legislative framework for occupational safety and health. The Occupational Safety and Health Act, Cap. 236A of the Laws of Kenya (OSHA) is the primary statute governing workplace safety. It places clear obligations on employers to provide and maintain a safe working environment, to ensure systems of work are safe, to provide adequate information, instruction, training, and supervision, and to put in place a written safety and health policy, where more than five employees are engaged. OSHA also establishes DOSHS under the Ministry of Labour and Social Protection, mandated to enforce these standards through workplace inspections and investigation of accidents. Beyond OSHA, the Work Injury Benefits Act, Cap. 236B of the Laws of Kenya (WIBA) provides for compensation to workers who suffer occupational injuries and diseases.

OSHA provides for fines and imprisonment for employers who breach its provisions. DOSHS can issue improvement notices, prohibition notices, and recommend prosecution of offenders. WIBA, on the other hand, exposes non-compliant employers to significant financial liability. However, workplaces continue to record preventable fatalities and serious injuries. Annual reports from the Kenya National Bureau of Statistics and DOSHS consistently document thousands of occupational accidents across sectors.

 

What a Compliance Culture Looks Like

Most employers treat safety as a regulatory exercise and rarely integrate it into the culture of the organisation.  When safety is treated as a compliance exercise, it manifests in predictable ways. The safety policy is framed, safely stored/filed, and barely discussed again. Safety training happens during induction, and while incidents are recorded in a register, they are investigated mostly to close the file, not necessarily to improve existing systems. Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) is often stored until an inspection date. Reporting incidents is quietly discouraged because recorded incidents affect performance metrics and invite scrutiny. Workers who raise concerns are sometimes labelled difficult and, in some instances, the said workers have complained of alleged victimization at the workplace if they lodge a complaint for compensation, for the injury suffered.

Compliance with OSHA should be the minimum standard any employer should meet. It should be the baseline, not the benchmark. An organisation that treats safety purely as a regulatory exercise will always find itself in a reactive position. It will conduct a risk assessment because an inspector is coming and to evaluate risks for the organisation. It will hold a fire drill because the certificate is due for renewal, not because it is an important exercise for its staff. It will issue PPE in compliance with the law and then fail to check whether anyone is using them correctly. Under OSHA, an employer doing all of the above is arguably compliant. However, this approach prioritises documentation over actual protection. When safety is driven purely by the fear of an audit or an inspector’s visit, it becomes a very cosmetic exercise.

A truly safe workplace is one where safety is embedded in how decisions are made at every level. This happens when an organisation treats safety as a value, something it holds because it is the right thing to do, not because DOSHS might show up. A safety culture must be led from the top and reinforced at every level of the organisation.

 

What a Safety Culture Should Look Like

A safety culture is the sum of the beliefs, behaviour, and norms that shape how people act when no one is watching, and especially when following the safe route is inconvenient. In organisations where safety is regarded as a culture, it shows up not only in documents, but in daily decisions, in how leadership behaves, and in what the organisation rewards and tolerates.

This culture starts with leadership. In workplaces where safety is genuinely valued, the leadership does not simply hand safety duties to the safety officer and move on. They follow up. They ask whether issues have been addressed and whether workers are actually safer, as a result.

In Kenya, where hierarchical workplace structures remain common, this top-down commitment is not optional, but it is essential. When employees see that safety matters as a priority for leaders, they view it as important and consider it a priority as well.

Further, organisations that take safety seriously also invest in it. They budget proactively for training, equipment maintenance, medical surveillance, and wellness programmes, before an incident forces the conversation. Employers who view those costs as investments, rather than impositions tend to have far safer workplaces. The reverse is also true. When safety budgets are the first to be cut, the message to employees is that their safety is not taken seriously, nor is it guaranteed.

One of the most important elements of a safety culture is the meaningful involvement of employees themselves. Section 9 of OSHA provides for the establishment of safety and health committees, in workplaces with more than twenty (20) employees. These committees are not supposed to be ceremonial. Workers, particularly those on the front lines of any operation, often have the most direct and detailed knowledge of what is dangerous in practice. Organisations that treat these committees seriously, genuinely listen to what workers require, and act on it and as a result, build systems far more durable than a compliant safety register. They create workplaces where safety is owned collectively, not outsourced to a department.

This same logic extends to how near misses are treated. A near miss is a situation where something almost caused a disaster in the workplace. It is one of the most valuable sources of safety insights available. In a compliance culture, near misses go unreported because workers fear blame, there is no system to capture them, or experience has taught them that nothing will change anyway. However, in a safety culture, near misses are investigated with the same seriousness as actual incidents, because the only difference between a near miss and a fatality is often luck, and an astute leadership understands that luck runs out, and the damage may be irreversible.

 

How Organisations Can Bridge the Gap in Safety Culture

For organisations willing to be honest about the gap between their current practice and a genuine safety culture, the shift does not require a complete overhaul. It requires intention, consistency, and a willingness to move from performance to principle. It begins with visible leadership commitment, not through memos, but through consistent actions that prioritises safety as a core organisational value.

This should be followed by conducting an honest assessment of the current safety culture, not just compliance status, while meaningfully engaging employees in identifying hazards and designing controls that address them. Additionally, it involves reviewing whether the safety committee is functioning as OSHA intends, or whether it exists only on paper, while also investing in training that builds genuine competence and awareness, not just induction processes. Finally, it is also good practice to create psychological safety for employees to raise concerns, without fear of being sidelined or dismissed.

It is important to note that none of this replaces compliance with OSHA. The policies, risk assessments, trained first aiders, accident registers, and DOSHS notifications remain necessary and non-negotiable. However, compliance becomes far easier and far more meaningful, when it is underpinned by a culture that values the people behind the policies.

 

Conclusion

On this World Day for Safety and Health at Work, it is important to understand that the real measure of an organisation’s commitment to its people, is not whether the DOSHS inspector finds everything in order, but whether workers feel safe, heard, and protected. Building and promoting this kind of safety culture is not a legal obligation.  It is a deliberate and intentional choice.

Ready, Set, Innovate: How Patent Protection Can Enhance the Accessibility of Sports in Kenya

Observed on the 26th of April each year, the World Intellectual Property Day invites us to reflect on how the legal protection of intellectual property encourages the progress of human innovation. The 2026 theme, “IP and Sports: Ready, Set, Innovate,” highlights a growing reality: modern sport is no longer defined by talent alone, but by technology, data, and design.

This year’s theme is particularly apt in today’s world. The world of sports is becoming increasingly shaped by technology, connectivity, equipment design, data and innovation. Through this year’s theme, the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) encourages the recognition of the importance of protecting and promoting inventions, designs, and brands that keep the sporting world dynamic, competitive and accessible.

 

Recent Technological Innovation in Sports

One illustration of the transformative power of modern technology in sports is the recent account of Mr. Clarke Reynolds, a blind runner and braille artist, who successfully completed the Brighton Marathon using Ray-Ban Meta Smart Glasses operated via the “Be My Eyes” application.

This feat of human ingenuity was accomplished using the help of remote volunteers who were able to view Mr. Reynolds’ surroundings through the glasses and offer real-time guidance in landscape navigation. This achievement serves as a compelling demonstration of how a combination of technology, innovation, connectivity and human support can expand the limits of participation for differently abled members of society.

Such a significant accomplishment lies not only in the determination of one athlete, but in the dedication of inventors to the future of inclusivity in sport. If properly protected and responsibly commercialized, assistive technologies such as these can play a crucial part in being not only exceptional individual stories, but also provide scalable solutions for schools, sports clubs, para-athletes and community programmes at large.

Although the precise patent status of the particular features used by Mr. Reynolds would require a dedicated patent search, the wider smart glasses sector is already the subject of active patent protection and enforcement.

In January 2026, for example, Solos Technology filed patent infringement proceedings against Meta Platforms and EssilorLuxottica in relation to smart glasses technology, alleging infringement of patents concerning audio, sensing and processing features used in smart eyewear.

This underscores the commercial and legal significance of protecting the technical systems that make such assistive sporting applications possible. While this example is global, it raises an important question: how can similar innovations be developed, protected, and scaled within Kenya?

The Kenyan context already offers a local parallel from an innovation perspective. In 2024, KCA University students were reported to have developed Artificial Intelligence (AI) powered smart glasses for visually impaired users, integrating Google Maps, computer vision and generative AI to support navigation, object recognition and audio description of surroundings. Although such technology is not confined to sport, its potential application in inclusive sport is evident.

 

The Role of Patent Protection in Encouraging Technological Innovation

Kenya is internationally recognised for its sporting talent, particularly in athletics. However, Kenya must move beyond producing exceptional talent, but also developing technologies, devices and systems that make sports safer and more accessible.

At its core, patent protection encourages inventors to develop, disclose, and commercialise new technological solutions. Where their inventions are new, involve an inventive step, and are industrially applicable, inventors may access legally recognised protections over their creations. It is from this position of security that inventors can rest assured that the fruits of their creativity are protected from unauthorized exploitation.

Kenya’s patent system should therefore be viewed as part of the country’s broader sports development infrastructure. If inventors believe their ideas can be protected, they are more likely to build, test, disclose, improve and commercialise them. However, challenges remain. Limited patent awareness, high registration costs, and weak industry-academia linkages continue to hinder the growth of sports innovation in Kenya.

Patent literacy should become part of Kenya’s sports innovation ecosystem. Coaches, athletes, sports federations, universities, technical training institutions, manufacturers, start-ups and investors should be encouraged to identify patentable inventions early.

If universities, technical institutes and start-ups understand the value of patent registration, they are more likely to invest in sports science and sports technology. If local manufacturers appreciate the commercial value of patented inventions, they are more likely to partner with inventors rather than merely import finished products.

 

Protection under the Industrial Property Act, (Cap. 509), Laws of Kenya

Under section 30 of the Industrial Property Act, (Cap. 509), Laws of Kenya (the “IPA”), a patent once granted provides its registered proprietor with enforceable protective rights over the invention.

However, patent protection must also be pursued carefully. Not every idea is patentable. A general concept, business method, abstract aspiration or untested proposal will not ordinarily suffice. The invention must meet the legal requirements of novelty, inventive step and industrial applicability. Prior disclosure may also affect novelty, which means that inventors should obtain legal advice before publishing, pitching, demonstrating or publicly testing an invention.

According to section 21 of the IPA, an “invention” means a solution to a specific problem in the field of technology. Section 22 of the IPA goes further to expressly specify that an invention is patentable if it is new, involves an inventive step and, is industrially applicable.

Where these legal pre-conditions are met, patent registration transforms an idea into a protectable asset that can be licensed, assigned, used to attract investment, commercialised through local manufacturing, or deployed through partnerships with schools, sports federations, corporate sponsors and disability inclusion programmes.

Additionally, sections 23 and 24 of the IPA provide that an invention is new if it is not anticipated by prior art and shall be considered as involving an inventive step if, having regard to the prior art relevant to the application claiming the invention, it would not have been obvious to a person skilled in the art to which the invention pertains.

This protection is vital because the process of the invention of technology requires several rounds of repeated prototyping, testing in real sporting conditions, collaboration with athletes and input from engineers, coaches, physiotherapists, software developers or medical professionals. Without adequate protection, an inventor may fear that once the invention is disclosed, demonstrated or tested publicly, it may be copied by a better funded competitor.

In Apex Creative Ltd & another v Kartasi Industries Ltd [2011] KEHC 720 (KLR), the High Court (Ogola J) underscored the significance of registered industrial property rights in enforcement proceedings, holding that only a registered patent owner can institute infringement proceedings under the Industrial Property Act.

The importance of this legal framework becomes especially clear when one considers sports accessibility as not limited to elite athletes or high-end performance equipment, but also including assistive devices that can determine who is able to participate in sport in the first place, for instance, adaptive wheelchairs, prosthetic sports equipment, safer protective gear, affordable training aids, injury prevention devices, rehabilitation technologies, wearable monitoring tools and locally designed sports equipment can all contribute to a more inclusive sporting environment.

Patent protection and public access should therefore not be treated as opposing goals. Properly managed, patent rights can encourage both commercialisation and access. An inventor may license technology to local manufacturers, permit preferential use by schools or disability sports programmes, enter sponsorship supported distribution arrangements, or collaborate with public institutions to scale the invention responsibly. In this way, patent protection can serve both private reward and public benefit.

 

Conclusion

The future of sport in Kenya will be built by both athletic talent and shaped by the inventors who design better equipment, safer systems, adaptive devices, smarter training tools and technologies that allow more people to participate. Patent protection gives those inventors the confidence to innovate.

If properly utilized, patent protection can help transform sports innovation from isolated ideas into protected assets and commercial opportunities, for the benefit of the general public at large.

If Kenya is to remain a global sporting powerhouse, it must invest not only in athletes, but in the ideas that support them. Patent protection is not merely a legal tool, but a catalyst for inclusive, home-grown innovation that can redefine who gets to participate in sport.